Hemingway House and Museum
“It’s the best place I’ve ever been anytime, anywhere, flowers, tamarind trees, guava trees, coconut palms…Got tight last night on absinthe and did knife tricks.”—Ernest Hemingway
Key West in July. An explosion of tropical colors, pastel bungalows, red flame trees arching over streets and gardenias perfuming the air. Breezeless air hangs heavy; the rhythms of the island, slow and sweat-drenched. I came to join in the Hemingway Days Festival, an annual summer celebration of the author’s larger-than-life persona. This is the time when white-bearded Papa Look-Alikes stroll the streets in safari dress or khaki shorts.
Hemingway first came to Key West in 1928, accompanied by his second wife, Pauline, to pick up a Model A Ford roadster, a wedding gift from her Uncle Gus. Its delivery was delayed several weeks, so the dealership invited the Hemingways to stay in an apartment above the showroom. He worked on A Farewell to Arms there and fell in love with the sleepy fishing village.
They returned in 1931, bought the house on Whitehead Street, and raised two sons. The great thing about the Hemingway House guides is that they tell tales. Some may be apocryphal, but they certainly jazz up the tour. Steve, our guide, blamed the stylish Pauline for our sweaty discomfort. She had all the ceiling fans removed and replaced with electric chandeliers crafted in Europe. With no central air and 20 tourists in our group, we relied on the sad upright fans in each room.
The second-floor balcony gave us a burst of fresh air and a look at the nearby lighthouse. In the 1930s, it offered a beacon to Hemingway whenever he emerged from a bar – Sloppy Joe’s was a favorite – and sloshed his way home. Joe Russell, the bar’s owner and Hemingway’s buddy, became outraged when his landlord raised rent a dollar per month. He and patrons ripped out sinks, urinals, whatever, before they vacated.
One of those urinals, flipped on its side, now adorns the Hemingway garden, although Hemingway claimed to have no recollection of how it got there. Today it provides a fresh water bowl for the cats, but when the lovely Pauline first saw it, she protested. Her husband prevailed, arguing, “I passed a fortune through this urinal.”
Forty-four cats – that day’s count – trace their origins to Hemingway’s Snowball, a six-toed (polydactyl) gift from a sea captain. Females are allowed one litter before spaying. Only a few toms roam the property; the remaining males are neutered and serve as “consultants.” Half of all the kittens are born with the genetic polydactyl trait. Steve explained Hemingway believed the polydactyls brought good luck and, since he was accident prone, he needed a larger share of luck.
Pablo Picasso, knowing Hemingway’s fondness for cats, gave him an abstract ceramic cat in Paris. A reproduction sits on a cabinet in the upstairs bedroom because the original, from the 1920s, was stolen in 2000. The thief smashed the cat before being apprehended. Steve snarled that Key West’s old hanging tree still exists, and suggested that lynching would have provided a more suitable resolution than the burglar’s short jail stint. If rope were available to our tour group, I think a mob could have formed.

Hemingway called Key West home from 1931 until 1939 and wrote 70% of his work here, including For Whom the Bell Tolls, “The Snows of Kilimanjaro,” To Have and Have Not, Green Hills of Africa, and “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber.” The house’s interior reflects Pauline, but the second floor of the old carriage house, Hemingway’s writing study, pulls us into his world. Horned animal heads and fish hanging on the walls remind us of his passion for the outdoors. A small round table holding a typewriter anchors the room. The chair is the kind used by Cuban cigar makers. Visitors showed a greater solemnity in this room because miracles happened here.
Despite the heat, we regretted leaving the compound. The only thing to be done was cross the street to toast Papa, man and myth, with a cold mojito.
—Ann Marie Byrd
Captain Edward Murphy of the SS Commodore (pictured right) recounted his crew’s desperate struggle for survival. Actually, the delightful John Mann, a Ponce Inlet Lighthouse volunteer, assumed Murphy’s persona at Lilian House’s 2012 Stephen Crane Festival in March. Stephen Crane recuperated here after his harrowing experience at sea – although nightmares haunted him for the remainder of his short life.
It’s no surprise that the house has attracted a supernatural spirit. Lucille, a ghost, is a long-time resident of Lilian Place. On the second floor, “Lucille’s Room” contains several dollhouses.
The SS Commodore was the finest of the filibustering fleet. A century ago filibuster meant privately funded military campaigns against foreign nations. The Cuban Junta’s leadership in New York had acquired the Commodore, a former harbor tug, and assigned her to Jacksonville, Florida. She made several successful trips to Cuba at a time when it was illegal to supply guns to rebels hoping to overthrow Spanish loyalists.
Six miles from Lilian Place stands the lighthouse. On the nights of January 2 and 3, 1897, lighthouse keeper Thomas Patrick O’Hagan and assistants carried the kerosene 203 steps up the tower, as they did each evening, in 40-pound containers. They gave Crane that glimmer of hope. The lighthouse property contains exhibits on the keepers and their families and a lens exhibit. Each night the lighthouse continues operating, although now a 1,000-watt lamp operated by volunteers provides private aid for navigation.
Little Women (1868), Louisa’s beloved classic, is set in Orchard House, so a visit is like paying a call on the March family. The Alcotts owned eighty percent of the furnishings on display. There’s the piano Marmee played in the parlor (pictured right), where guests sat as the girls performed Monday evening dramas, songs and dances in the adjacent dining room. Meg and John married in the parlor, where sunlight spills through the windows.
Louisa wasn’t the only breadwinner in the household. Her earnings allowed May (Amy) to study art in Paris. May’s sketches of mythological characters, especially women with their children, and biblical characters are visible on the walls of Orchard House, now preserved under plexiglass. Bronson encouraged her to draw, and if paper were unavailable, there were always walls. May’s bedroom, where most of the drawings appear, is a bright and airy addition, provided by Bronson especially for his artistic daughter. It’s a long, high room that was perfect for May, who stood 5’11”. May’s enduring legacy lies in the fact that she gave Daniel Chester French his first art and sculpture lessons. French went on to design the solemn Abraham Lincoln statue that sits in the Lincoln Memorial. To commemorate May, French used some of the first plastering tools she ever gave him on this piece.
The Alcotts are buried in Sleepy Hollow Cemetery. I walked through the graveyard to Authors Ridge, the resting place among the pines for the Alcott Family, Nathaniel and Sophia Hawthorne, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Henry David Thoreau. Previous visitors had left flowers and fountain pens at her grave. Behind it stands a white marble marker with her name on it, along with a circular sign indicating she was a veteran. Louisa served in Washington, D.C., as a Union nurse in the Civil War. Like many nurses, she came down with typhoid pneumonia. The treatment involved calomel (mercury chloride) and resulted in Louisa developing mercury poisoning. She returned home to recover and write her most famous work and more. Louisa died at the age of 55 on March 6, 1888, two days after her father’s death.

